The basic concept of purchasing power parity theory or ppp relates to the purchasing power of a dollar. A puzzle concerning purchasing power parity is examined. It is important in international economics for at least three reasons. A countrys exports would always buy exactly the same basket. Purchasing power parity is based on an economic theory that states the prices of goods and services should equalize among countries over time. Dean corbae and sam ouliaris 1988, cointegration and tests of purchasing power parity 10. Sampling and specification biases in meanreversion tests of the law of one price alan m. Obstfeld and rogoff 2000 identified the purchasing power and exchange. The law of one price a case study, cesifo working paper series 428, cesifo group munich. If purchasing power parity held, then the real exchange rate would always equal one. Rogoff 1996 described the ppp puzzle as the embarrassing resiliency of the random walk model, where ppp does not hold in the shortrun, and convergence is in. Papell university of houston abstract the purchasing power parity puzzle is the difficulty of reconciling very high shortterm volatility of real exchange rates with very slow rates of mean reversion. Purchasing power parity in tradable goods request pdf. The purchasing power parity ppp doctrine, one of the most widely researched areas in international finance, is also probably one of the most controversial in the theory of exchange rate determination.
I have a sample exam question that says from your reading explain what the ppp puzzle is and i am finding it hard to understand, i have tried to read the kenneth rogoff arcticle but it is extremley difficult to understand. Basically, he proposed calculating cumu lative cpi inflation rates from the begin ning of 1914 and using these inflation differentials to calculate the exchange rate changes needed to maintain ppp. For purchasing power parity to hold in the long run, real exchange rates must be stationary. Purchasing power parity by meher manzur, 9781847209429, available at book depository with free delivery worldwide. Obstfeld and rogoffs 2000 6 major puzzles in macroeconomics with essentially the same explanation.
Abstractthis paper investigates purchasingpower parity ppp since the late nineteenth century. The purchasing power parity puzzle and imperfect knowledge. I collected data for a group of twenty countries over 100 years, a larger historical panel of annual data than has ever been studied. Dean corbae and sam ouliaris 1988, cointegration and tests of purchasing power parity10. Another look at the evidence, journal of international economics, elsevier, vol. International trade allows people to shop around for the best price. These two anomalies are sometimes referred to as the purchasing power parity puzzles. Published in volume 18, issue 4, pages 5158 of journal of economic perspectives, fall 2004, abstract. The purchasing power parity puzzle kenneth rogoff journal of economic literature, vol. An example of a good for which the lop may be expected to hold is gold and other internationally traded commodities see rogoff, 1996. Purchasing power parity ppp, the straightforward theory that real prices of goods across countries should converge, has been remarkably difficult to confirm in empirical work.
Purchasing power parity ppp a theory of exchange rate determination based on traders motivations that result in a ppp exchange rate when there are no transportation costs and no differential taxes applied. Perspectives on ppp and longrun real exchange rates, with ken froot, in. Oct 16, 2017 the purchasing power parity puzzle is the title of the book written by eminent economist kenneth roggof that deals with the extremely high shortterm volatility of the real exchange rates. The purchasing power parity puzzle, journal of economic literature, american economic association, vol. Purchasing power parity ppp is a disarmingly simple theory that holds that. The purchasing power parity puzzle is but one manifestation of a broader range of puzzles which obstfeld and rogoff 2000b call the exchangerate discon nect puzzle. The purchasing power parity puzzle is worse than you think christian j. This chapter discusses the law of one price lop, the basic building block of purchasing power parity ppp. The real exchangerate puzzles is a common term for two muchdiscussed anomalies of real exchange rates. The latter category of riddles includes both the meeserogoff exchange rate forecasting puzzle and the baxterstockman neutrality of exchange rate regime puzzle. The latter category of riddles includes both the meese rogoff exchange rate forecasting puzzle and the baxterstockman neutrality of exchange rate regime puzzle. The six major puzzles in international macroeconomics. January 2004 abstract the purchasing power parity puzzle is the difficulty of reconciling very high shortterm volatility of real exchange rates with very slow rates of mean reversion. This paper provides a test of purchasing power parity ppp adjusted with the productivity differentials between tradable and nontradable goods balassasamuelson effect in the cases of indonesia and korea by applying johansen cointegration test and a multivariable regression model with quarterly data 1971.
The mirage of fixed exchange rates, with maurice obstfeld, journal of economic perspectives 9, fall 1995, 7396. Doctrinal perspective and evidence from the 1920s8. On the empirical failure of purchasing power parity tests. Deviations from purchasing power parity in the long run, journal of finance, american finance association, vol. Purchasing power parity across eight worlds sciencedirect. I am grateful to rudiger dornbusch, hali edison, ohn rogers, susanne trimbath, and to three anonymous referees for constructive suggestions on an earlier draft, and to brian doyle and giovanni olivei for excellent research assistance.
Mar 09, 2011 for purchasing power parity to hold in the long run, real exchange rates must be stationary. Potential pitfalls for the purchasingpowerparity puzzle. The striking feature of this figure is the very close correlation between real and nominal exchange rates indeed the average correlation coefficient across the six countries portrayed in figure 3. At the heart of the movement of foreign exchange rates is the change in a countrys balance of payments. Purchasing power parity ppp is the theoretical proposition that national currencies have the same real purchasing power at home and abroad. Rossi, 2010, can exchange rates forecast commodity prices. Ppp relies on the price of goods and services remaining constant across comparisons, often referred to as the law of one price. The evidence for longrun ppp is favorable using recent multivariate and univariate tests of higher power. Perspectives on ppp and longrun real exchange rates, with ken froot, in handbook of international economics vol.
Mar 31, 2010 i am trying to understand the ppp puzzle. View references in econpapers view complete reference list from citec. This paper provides a test of purchasing power parity ppp adjusted with the productivity differentials between tradable and nontradable goods balassasamuelson effect in the cases of indonesia and korea by applying johansen cointegration test and a multivariable regression model. This recent survey provides an overview of developments with respect to research on ppp, including the emerging consensus that deviations from ppp do damp out but only very slowly, at roughly fifteen percent per year. We also address a variety of international pricing puzzles, including the purchasing power parity puzzle emphasized by rogoff, and what we term the exchangerate disconnect puzzle.
Michael adler and bruce lehman 1983, deviations from purchasing power parity in the long run9. Purchasing power parity is a way of adjusting gdp to take account of the fact that the same good varies in price between countries, with a us dollar buying four or. The purchasing power parity puzzle 649 means for setting relative gold parities. David peel, phillip lane, kenneth rogoff, andrew rose, lucio sarno, timothy taylor, eric. How to calculate and use purchasing power parity ppp. The six major puzzles in international macroeconomics 341 competition plus sticky prices andor wages, as in the extensive recent literature on the new openeconomy macroeconomics. It is this purchasing power parity puzzle rogoff 1996 that misess subjectivist view on purchasing power of money can explain. Nov 07, 2008 purchasing power parity is a way of adjusting gdp to take account of the fact that the same good varies in price between countries, with a us dollar buying four or five times as much in china or. The purchasing power parity puzzle kenneth rogoff journal.
Potential pitfalls for the purchasing power parity puzzle. The purchasing power parity puzzle kenneth rogoff journal of. The case of the polish zloty, central european journal of economic modelling and econometrics, cejeme, vol. Almost all previous studies that have tested the law of one price or purchasing power parity theory ppp have used either real effective exchange rates or bilateral real exchange rates which are constructed using cpi or ppi data.
The purchasing power parity persistence paradigm christian j. Most notably, with lower trade frictions, domestic investment becomes much less correlated with domestic saving, mitigating the feldsteinhorioka 1980 puzzle. The purchasing power parity puzzle kennethrogoff princeton university i am grateful to rudiger dornbusch, hali edison, ohn rogers, susanne trimbath, and to three anonymous referees for constructive suggestions on an earlier draft, and to brian doyle and giovanni olivei for excellent research assistance. Apr 03, 2011 for purchasing power parity to hold in the long run, real exchange rates must be stationary. Although we do not present such a model here, we do demonstrate why trade costs. On the purchasing power parity puzzle sciencedirect. The purchasing power parity puzzle, journal of economic literature 34, june 1996, 64768. Essay about the purchasing power parity puzzle 12509 words. Papell university of houston june 29, 2000 abstract rogoff 1996 describes the remarkable consensus of 35 year halflives of purchasing power parity deviations among studies using longhorizon data. View references in econpapers view complete reference list. This paper do not try to solve the ppp puzzle, instead, to give positive evidence to support the purchasing power parity. The purchasing power parity puzzle, journal of economic literature, 342, june 1996, pages 647668. Nominal gdp becomes less variable while real gdp becomes much more closely tied to nominal gdp, mitigating the purchasing power parity and exchange rate disconnect puzzles.
The ppp measures how much a currency can buy in terms of an international measure usually dollars, since goods and services have different prices in. Purchasing power parity purchasing power parity or ppp expresses the notion that with a unit of purchasing power, say one dollar or one euro, it should be possible to purchase the same bundle of goods and services anywhere in the world. It mainly focuses on internationally tradable goods and services, rather than broad. Although the immense exchange rate volatility suggests a likely major role of nominal shocks under sticky prices, the observed halflife persistence of the real exchange rate seems excessively high to be rationalized by price stickiness. Purchasing power parity as an explanation of longterm changes in exchange rates, journal of money, credit and banking, blackwell publishing, vol. Empirical panel data evidence for post brettonwoods period mingming zheng. Empirical research on the validity of the purchasing power parity ppp condition is generally based on real exchange rates built using the consumer price index cpi, but fails to provide clear. Simply put, while the exchange rate seems to gyrate wildly, it does not appear to feed back into the real economy with neasly the force and speed that one would expect for. This immediately makes the point that purchasing power parity cannot hold on a shortrun basis. Purchasing power parity and the real exchange rate 67 4an example often used in the literature is the product differentiation of mcdonalds hamburgers across countries. The purchasing power parity puzzle is the title of the book written by eminent economist kenneth roggof that deals with the extremely high shortterm volatility of the real exchange rates. The purchasing power parity debate american economic.
Obstfeld, maurice, and rogoff, kenneth 2000, the six major puzzles in. Pppespecially for the postbretton woods periodas the first ppp puzzle. Originally propounded by the sixteenthcentury scholars of the university of salamanca, the concept of purchasing power pa. Purchasing power parity ppp is measured by finding the values in usd of a basket of consumer goods that are present in each country such as pineapple juice, pencils, etc. Purchasing power parity simple english wikipedia, the. Rogofl the purchasing power parity puzzle 649 means for setting relative gold parities. Productivity differentials and purchasing power parity. Papell university of houston abstract the purchasing power parity puzzle is the difficulty of reconciling very high shortterm volatility of real exchange rates with very slow rates of. I adopt potential bias adjustments used by choi, mark and sul 2006.
215 1556 793 1465 1196 1621 41 685 1609 1191 266 1130 586 1500 322 1643 267 811 283 1671 1059 1244 16 192 537 862 301 816 1021 1144 615 352 648 1301